Learning Communities 10/23/008

This weeks readings focused on a lot of ideas but one of the most compelling was the idea of capitalism and race merging.  I was very glad to see a discussion of class happening in this article because I feel like it’s been left out of the conversation.  While we have done a lot of discussion on race/diversity we haven’t spoken much about class or gender. What I liked about this article was that it highlighted how social construction is built upon a multitude of factors- race, class, gender (and sexual orientation) combined.  Not one of these aspects of self exists individually.  Someone isn’t just black, they are a black man or a black woman, which significantly changes their position in society.  You aren’t just white, you’re straight and white or gay and white (or bi and white/trans and white) which effects how you are perceived in the white community. Also, you aren’t just any race or gender, if you are of the working class that effects your position within your racial or gender group as much as any other.  

I appreciated the ways in which the Johnson piece highlighted how racism and classism have been used together to perpetuate inequality.  One of the most relevant examples that Johnson brings up is the issue of out sourcing, or even of immigrants coming in and “taking our jobs”.  The fact is, those jobs are being taken away but not by Mexican immigrants.  It’s a systemic problem- Managers need to pay less for more and their white workers are asking for a raise/healthcare/daycare or all of the above. Instead of paying, they outsource or lay off employees and hire illegal workers to do the same work for cheaper.  The immigrants/outsourced workers accept the job because they too need money to keep a roof over their head or put food on their table.  They are taking the jobs that they are offered to make their lives work, not to take away from white workers.  This is an amazing set up by the corporations because they get what they want while passing the buck.  The blame stays on people who are only trying to live from people who are also only trying to live and the winners in the whole situation make more money and live better than both cheated parties combined and times ten.  

It’s important to understand the important message that Johnson made because it is vital that we stop blaming others for our situations when they may not be at fault.  

On a side note, I found an early part of the “Where I’m From” reading compelling considering the events of this past Saturday.

“The ways we organize classroom life should seek to make children feel significant and cared about — by the teacher and by each other. Unless students feel emotionally and physically safe, they won’t share real thoughts and feelings. Discussions will be tinny and dishonest. We need to design activities where students learn to trust and care for each other. Classroom life should, to the greatest extent possible, prefigure the kind of democratic and just society we envision and thus contribute to building that society. Together students and teachers can create a “community of conscience,” as educators Asa Hilliard and George Pine call it (p. 4).”

I did not feel safe after the events of Saturday.  I don’t feel comfortable sharing certain thoughts and feelings anymore because I don’t know that I’m not going to be publicaly called out and embarrassed. I now worry about coming to a professor with an issue or opinion because I’m not sure it will be be valued or believed; after Saturday, the trust and safety is gone.  I’m not sure what has to be done to reconcile that, and in the end I can only speak for myself.  I’m sure the needs of others are going to be different and so what needs to be done to recreate a safe environment is going up to each other.

3 thoughts on “Learning Communities 10/23/008

  1. Right On Megan,

    I too was excited to talk about capitalist influences on race. Examining the the political and economic influences on racism is vital. I also think it is important to discuss the influence religion has played in such bias of gender and sexual orientation upon our postionality.

    I too observed the irony of last Saturday’s event in relation to the our reading and most of the material and ideology we are be trained in at PacU. Though what happened completely contradicted much of what we are learning, I am grateful for the genuine models of educators we are receiving in Mark and Nancy. I am also proud of our cohort and optimistic of what kind of teachers we will become. I look forward to resolving the conflict and learning how to rebuild a healthy classroom climate.

    Live well,

  2. Megan-

    I just wanted to share how I too found the reading as ironic. This very passage that you quoted was what keep echoing in my head. I really feel that looking back on it we will learn from the experience. We know have the first hand knowledge of how being treated that way feels. Just as the reading suggested we will certainly be aware of making a classroom in which students are valued. One that they feel safe to share and capable of growing.

    Thanks for sharing-

  3. Megan, You wrote a lot about events of which I was not a part. You make yourself very clear and it helps me understand. I might also suggest looking at this through other lenses, as a way to expand its potential as a learning opportunity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *